Can All Elements Directly Transition From Solid To Gas?

Table of Contents (click to expand)

Yes, all elements can directly transition from solid to gas.

It is common knowledge that there are 3 states of matter: solid, liquid and gas. Usually, elements transition from solid to liquid to gas, or in the reverse order, depending on the change in surroundings.

However, it is also possible to have a direct solid to gas or gas to solid change.

When thinking of such a transition, the most common element that comes to mind is Iodine.

Throughout my primary education, any chapter that related to the states of matter spoke of Iodine and naphthalene being among the few elements that are capable of a direct solid to gas transition.

However, this is actually a misconception.

What Is Sublimation?

Sublimation is the direct change of an element from the solid phase to the gaseous phase, without going through the liquid phase, at a specific temperature and pressure. The reverse process, i.e., changing from gas to solid directly, is called deposition.

As mentioned above, Iodine is one of the common examples of substances that can sublimate. Others include naphthalene and dry ice or carbon dioxide. You may have noticed that mothballs, which are made of naphthalene, shrink and disappear over time. This is because they also sublimate from their solid state directly into a gaseous state. Therefore, they are converted into fumes and ‘disappear’.

Mothballs sublimate and disappear (Photo Credit : twenty20)

Similarly, if you’ve ever seen dry ice, it is impossible to not notice the thick white fumes that it gives off. This, again, is a visual example of sublimation. Dry ice is nothing but solidified carbon dioxide. At room temperature, it will directly convert to gas and the fumes you can see are gaseous carbon dioxide.

However, almost all elements are capable of sublimation under the right temperature and pressure conditions.

Also Read: What Happens To A Gas When Its Pressure Is Increased?

What Is A Phase Diagram And Why Is It Important?

A phase diagram of a substance is a graph with temperature and pressure on the x and y axis, respectively. It shows the various temperatures and pressures at which a particular phase of the substance—solid, liquid or gas—can exist and remain stable.

There are three solid lines in the diagram. These show the temperatures and pressures at which the various phases are in equilibrium with each other, i.e., when they can exist together. These lines also denote when phase transition will occur, or, in other words, when the substance will change from one phase to another. The areas marked by the lines show the three phases. For instance, consider the phase diagram for water, as shown below.

Needless to say, the phase diagram for different elements will be different.

On a phase diagram, the 3 solid lines will intersect at one point, known as the triple point. As mentioned above, the lines also show the equilibrium between phases.

Therefore, the triple point denotes the point when all three phases – solid, liquid and gas – can exist in equilibrium with each other.

binary phase diagram of water - H2O
(Photo Credit : magnetix/Shutterstock)

Also Read: Can A Metal Be Gas?

Triple Point And Sublimation

As you can see from the phase diagram, the curve at the bottom shows the transition between the solid and gaseous states. The liquid phase cannot exist below the triple point. Therefore, at any point below the triple point, most substances, when heated, will sublimate from solid to gas.

Conversely, at any point above the triple point, we will even see elements like iodine and carbon dioxide go through a liquid phase.

For most elements, however, the triple point is below normal temperature and pressure conditions (NTP), which is a pressure of 1 atm and a temperature of ~20°C. This is why we cannot see them undergo sublimation. However, even substances like water can undergo sublimation, when exposed to conditions below their triple point. For water, these are is 0.1°C and 0.006 atm.

Let’s consider one of our previous examples again. The triple point of carbon dioxide (dry ice) is ~5 atm and -56.6°C. At normal pressure, i.e. 1 atm, as the dry ice is heated, it will directly go to the gas stage, or sublimate. This example shows that even though the temperature is not below the triple point temperature, sublimation will occur. This is because when we look at the phase diagram for carbon dioxide, NTP conditions lie below the triple point, even though the temperature, individually, is less than that of the triple point temperature. Therefore, it is important to note that sublimation will occur at any point below the triple point.

binary phase diagram of water - H2O
Phase Diagram of Carbon Dioxide  (Photo Credit : Ben Finne/Wikimedia commons)

It is also important to note that phase diagrams apply at ideal conditions, meaning that they apply to a single, pure substance in a closed system at equilibrium. These conditions are never met practically, so deviations are to be expected.

In theory, although most elements can undergo sublimation, it’s not possible to practically achieve those conditions. Therefore, in practice, it is best to consider the few ideal elements like iodine, naphthalene and carbon dioxide as examples of elements that can sublimate.

How well do you understand the article above!

Can you answer a few questions based on the article you just read?

References (click to expand)
  1. Sublimation | COSMOS. The Centre for Astrophysics and Supercomputing
  2. Sublimation | Physics Van | UIUC. The University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  3. Sublimation and Phases. | Physics Van | UIUC. The University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  4. Triple Point of Water | UCSC Physics Demonstration Room. The University of California, Santa Cruz
  5. Phase Diagrams. Purdue University
  6. Triple Point of CO2. The University of California, Santa Barbara
Help us make this article better
About the Author

Mahak Jalan has a BSc degree in Zoology from Mumbai University in India. She loves animals, books and biology. She has a general assumption that everyone shares her enthusiasm about the human body! An introvert by nature, she finds solace in music and writing.